[Sempai-Kun]

The challenge:

Same Stock/Render 1 on 1 battle!

The Challengers:
Sempai-Kun:


SasuraiZero:


First to 5 wins!

PLEASE BASE YOUR VOTES ON A GRAPHICAL OPINION. VOTES W/O A REASON POSTED HERE WILL NOT BE COUNTED.


Example of what NOT to do:

-I like this character so I vote for [insert member here]
-The signature looks cute

Example of how to vote:

1. it shows good movement through the vector flow design.
2. The vector design fits the used render very well and reeally blends with the character's movement.
3. The colors/lighting/shading all fit very well which gives a great outlook on the completed entry for this SOTW.
4. Has great use od design principals to make it stand out above the others in my opinion.
5. Finally, it looks the best of all the others (other than my own, lol which I can't vote for, lol) in my opinion.

[phazer11]

Well it's hard to choose any specific things we should be rating like any specific themes that are supposed to be represented in the new image?

[Orpheus24]

-vote witheld-

[SVKnight]

Originally Posted by Orpheus24

I like better Sempai-Kun's render better

Off: They had the same render...-_-"

On:
Sempai-kun:

• Looks very simple for me(comparing to his other sigs).
• The render is small and i cant see the face well.
• Has a very nice idea though.

SasuraiZero:

• The flame(or what u call it) on the lower left side seems out of place to me.
• The vertical lines and the horizontal line near the render seems not quite appealing to me.
• I cant really understand it well.

In the end my vote goes to SasuraiZero 'cause i think its more appealing than Sempai's
Note: This is just my opinion.

[Sempai-Kun]

Originally Posted by phazer11

Well it's hard to choose any specific things we should be rating like any specific themes that are supposed to be represented in the new image?

Example of what NOT to do:

-I like this character so I vote for [insert member here]
-The signature looks cute

Example of how to vote:

1. it shows good movement through the vector flow design.
2. The vector design fits the used render very well and reeally blends with the character's movement.
3. The colors/lighting/shading all fit very well which gives a great outlook on the completed entry for this SOTW.
4. Has great use od design principals to make it stand out above the others in my opinion.
5. Finally, it looks the best of all the others (other than my own, lol which I can't vote for, lol) in my opinion.

just use that as a guideline...

[phazer11]

1. it shows good movement through the vector flow design.
2. The vector design fits the used render very well and reeally blends with the character's movement.
3. The colors/lighting/shading all fit very well which gives a great outlook on the completed entry for this SOTW.
4. Has great use od design principals to make it stand out above the others in my opinion.
5. Finally, it looks the best of all the others (other than my own, lol which I can't vote for, lol) in my opinion.

Ok my vote goes to SasuraiZero
My opinion
Reasons
1. I think Sasurais show better rhythm and movement and shows more emotion
2. Motion fits with render well
3. Sasurai's has better lighting and complements the render's dark colors

Sempai Might improve on his by changing background color and removing glaring headache-inducing outline hope it helps.

[Happyumi]

My vote goes to Sasurai's....

• nice flow
• good text-work
• the use of c4d is simply great
• the size of the render fits the sig
• the feeling of the render is well shown

[BlueBlooded]

Sasurai gets mah vote too...
the sig has a good flow, and the render is blended well,also, the work on the text looks great, moreover the lines and circles give a good look, combined with the c4d.

[nejizz]

SasuraiZero:

Sasu gets my vote!!!


★ Very Awesome Flow about it.


★ I like the color's used and the blending of the render.


★ The sparks from her skates was a really nice effect.

[Vuki]

Sempai-Kun

The feeling is cleaner yet has a blur and because of the size of the signature and render, the idea of the character fading out or fading inward seems to be provoked. She's skating around the place, tagging everything as she goes. It feels like I should be watching an animation segment. The colors are more vibrant as well.