SOTW #4 Poll

[boneheadjoe]

FINISHED


Votes counting:

Elderkain - 2
Misuzu - 2
Crimsonblood - 1
SweetHoney - 2
sensei-kun - 3
Boneheadjoe - 2
Leaf - 1


Sensei-kun wins the #4 SOTW.


and please, this goes for all users who will post in the SOTW polls. If you want to discuss or anything, go make a thread somewhere else, next time infractions will be given out.


SOTW #4 ENTRIES:

Spoiler!

Misuzu-


Durmiente-


SweetHoney-


/\/\ao


Raging-



Ice Climbers-


polarbear-


crimsonblood-


Leaf-


sensei-kun-

ElderKain-


boneheadjoe-



bigdave-

[Dark_Clown]

me votes for elder ...

[Sensei-kun]

me votes for Misuzu

[darkJester]

pop outs are just not fair imo.....

that being said... my vote goes to ElderKain... ROFL....

[GEN]

lol i don't really think its true that pop outs aren't fair but i wont vote for them most the time just because of the simplicity in them even if the pop out made is a good one like elder kains

[ElderKain]

Lol, I normally vote for myself *nothing in the rules is against it*
but i'll vote for "crimsonblood"
I like the way the background and the Haruhi Render blend together.

Sry if being a popout sig is too unfair, but u gotta think, it all depends on the look.
In SOTW #3 Misuzu had a Sig with popout edges, and she didn't win, so u really can't say it's completly unfair.

[M to the C]

SweetHoney

Looks really good and well done, and the colours look good together

[4saken]

I'll vote for sensei-kun.

Not sure what you mean by popout sig. If it transparency+some stuff outside the border, then every other sig around is "a popout sig". The transparent part is still part of the space being used, so that doesn't really change much. If it's within the max dimensions anyone can just save as .png or .gif and leave part of their image outside the border *shrug*. If you mean using a drop shadow to make it look likes its poping off the background of the web page then misuzu didn't use one in the last contest. Either way its hard consider sigs with either of those things being used as something different from any other sig.

Edit, response to GEN's post below:

thats all nice and fun 4saken but ive been calling sigs like that pop out sigs for a year or so now and so have my gimp brotheren so im gonna still call them pop out sigs

I never said you shouldn't call it what you want, they just shouldn't be categorized differently is what I said. I call it "the use of transparency" myself(which I have been using for about 8 years since the first sig I made). lol...

[GEN]

thats all nice and fun 4saken but ive been calling sigs like that pop out sigs for a year or so now and so have my gimp brotheren so im gonna still call them pop out sigs

[凌乱の决心]

i vote for Sensei-kun i dont know i just love his work so much x.x