[toadvine]

From my experience it really just depends on the girl - they've all got different tastes, just like we do (simple example: blond hair does nothing for me but other guys go nuts for a blond lady.) Some will find a man attractive even as their friends are repulsed by his looks.

You'll never get two people to agree that "yes, *these* are the features that make someone physically attractive." Aside from obvious matters of taste, many people will fetishize something (glasses, hair type, muscles - one girl I know is absolutely obsessed with collar bones, for some reason.)

Ever notice how no matter how unlucky someone was with genetics, almost everyone gets hooked up at some point? Somewhere, there are people who will find ANYTHING attractive. I'm pretty sure it's a correlation to rule 34.