The first one, the purple border looks odd, and the render color really doesn't fit the background coloring.
As for the Text, the second one's text looks alright, The Font selection could be better, and the first sig could use some work text wise also.
Other than that, I like the second1 best.
Also, u should put Ur names on ur sigs just in case, because there are lots of people that steal sigs and clame them as their own...
~ Sig Ratings ~
Sig1: 4/10
Sig2: 9/10
Nice works ^.^
